Menu

Call This Wednesday to Get $50 OFF

Should You Get Your Tankless Water Heater Repaired or Replaced?
4.8 RATING

Should You Get Your Tankless Water Heater Repaired or Replaced?

When it comes to the comfort of your home, having an uninterrupted supply of hot water is non-negotiable. Crucial for everything from handwashing and showering…

765-228-2371
May 27, 2026
Should You Get Your Tankless Water Heater Repaired or Replaced?

When it comes to the comfort of your home, having an uninterrupted supply of hot water is non-negotiable. Crucial for everything from handwashing and showering to dishwashing and laundry, hot water is a basic necessity in the modern world. What's less considered is the water heater itself. It turns out there are many options, including tank-style and tankless water heaters. 

In this article brought to you by Rooter Man Plumbing, we explore the tankless models and dissect its life expectancy. If you’d like to consult with a trained plumber directly, then call Rooter Man Plumbing. We’re happy to arrange a face-to-face meeting or on-site appointment for as soon as possible.

Our Customer Reviews

Called Rooterman Plumbing of Muncie for a leaking pipe behind drywall. They serviced us within a few hours and we had our repair done by 5 p.m. Can't beat that! Thank you Rooterman Plumbing!

Veretta Teague

Yorktown, IN

Rooterman of Muncie is the best if you are having plumbing issues. Hands down best in the business in my opinion. From the start Lindsey handled the claim and the appointment for us. She was professional and very pleasant to deal with. We had to…

Cindy Goyak

Albany, IN

He's one of the most professional plumbers I've ever met really knows what he's doing very knowledgeable.And you guys are my plumbers. Anytime I need plumbing done, you guys will be doing my work very thankful that I found you.

Richard Moreillon

Richmond, IN

Dustin did an excellent job replacing our faulty gas line. He is professional, personable and very nice to work with. He explained options and processes very clearly. Our install required some challenges to overcome due to decking, grading, and structures. He explained possible plans of…

Sherri Keaton

Selma, IN

The Lifespan of Tankless Water Heaters

Tankless water heaters, also known as on-demand water heaters, have gained popularity for their energy efficiency and space-saving design. However, like any household appliance, they are not immune to wear and tear. While it depends on usage patterns, maintenance, and the quality of the unit, the average lifespan of a tankless water heater typically ranges between 15 to 20 years.

Signs Your Water Heater Needs Attention

That it can last 20 years does not mean your water heater will last 20 years. Keep your eyes – and nose and ears – peeled for signs of trouble. Here are some indications that your water heater may need a hand:

  • Decline in Performance: If you notice a decrease in the water temperature or a reduction in the volume of hot water produced, it could indicate mineral buildup, a failing heating element, or other internal problems. indicate mineral buildup, a failing heating element, or other internal problems.
  • Fluctuating Temperatures: Inconsistent water temperatures, where the water goes from hot to cold, can be frustrating. This issue may be related to a malfunctioning thermostat or a compromised flow sensor within the tankless unit.
  • Strange Noises: Unusual sounds, such as rattling, banging, or popping, can be indicative of sediment buildup within the unit. This sediment accumulation hinders the heating process and efficiency of the water heater.
  • Water Leaks: Any signs of water leakage around the unit warrant investigation. Leaks could be the result of a faulty pressure relief valve, loose connections, or internal corrosion, all of which necessitate immediate attention.

It’s wise to handle necessary water heater repair as soon as possible. Small issues can turn into big problems. For instance, sediment buildup can turn into scaling. This can cause the water heater to overwork and even overheat your water.

When to Replace Your Water Heater

When the plumbers investigate your water heater, they’ll determine the root cause of the problem and give you their expert opinion on the matter. Typically, we recommend a water heater replacement if:

  • If your tankless water heater is approaching or has surpassed its expected lifespan.
  • If the repair expenses are substantial and approach or exceed the cost of a replacement.
  • If your current unit is outdated and lacks safety and energy-saving features.

If you’d like to consult with a trained plumber, then call Rooter Man Plumbing and get in touch with uniformed professionals today. We look forward to taking your call.

Coupons

Rooter Man Plumbing Coupons & Specials

Offer Expires October 31, 2026
$50OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Offer Expires October 31, 2026
$1599

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Offer Expires October 31, 2026
$250OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Offer Expires October 31, 2026
$200OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Latest News & Updates

08 October 2026

The True Cost of Waiting: How a Tiny Drip Turns into a Major Renovation

While a small drip beneath your sink or a faint stain may not raise concerns initially, delaying professional intervention can…

Read More
04 October 2026

Why Recurring Main Line Clogs Keep Coming Back

Few plumbing problems are more frustrating than a drain that keeps clogging after it has already been cleared. You may…

Read More
28 September 2026

Is That Mysterious Under-Sink Leak Coming from Your Faucet Mount?

A small puddle beneath the kitchen or bathroom sink may seem like a minor inconvenience, but an unexplained leak can…

Read More
21 September 2026

Well Water vs. City Water in East Central Indiana: Tailoring Your Whole-House System

Water quality can vary significantly from one home to another in East Central Indiana. Some households rely on private wells,…

Read More